Adam Pascal & Heather Headley Lyrics — by Popularity
| 1 | Elaborate Lives |
| 2 | Elaborate Lives (Reprise) |
| 3 | Enchantment Passing Through |
| 4 | Enchantment Passing Through (Broadway Cast Recording) |
| 5 | My Strongest Suit (Reprise) |
| 6 | Written in the Stars |
| 1 | Elaborate Lives |
| 2 | Elaborate Lives (Reprise) |
| 3 | Enchantment Passing Through |
| 4 | Enchantment Passing Through (Broadway Cast Recording) |
| 5 | My Strongest Suit (Reprise) |
| 6 | Written in the Stars |