American Murder Song Lyrics — by Popularity
| 1 | A Black Matilda |
| 2 | A Body on the Step |
| 3 | August |
| 4 | Checkout |
| 5 | Edward |
| 6 | Hail Columbia! |
| 7 | I'm Always Walking as Somebody Else |
| 8 | Interrogation |
| 9 | Johnny |
| 10 | July |
| 11 | June |
| 12 | Lullaby |
| 13 | Mary |
| 14 | Murder! Murder! |
| 15 | Orientation |
| 16 | Pray |
| 17 | Pretty Lavinia |
| 18 | Pumped Up Kicks (Room 0) |
| 19 | Seduction |
| 20 | Six Merry Men |
| 21 | Sweet Rosalie |
| 22 | The Black Wagon |
| 23 | The Black Wagon Returns |
| 24 | The Cry of the Banished Horseman |
| 25 | The Devil in Camp |
| 26 | The Five Sisters |
| 27 | The Indiana Man |
| 28 | The Last Americans |
| 29 | The Wind Weeps Eleanor |
| 30 | The Year Without a Summer |
| 31 | Transformation |
| 32 | Unwed Henry |
| 33 | Wake Up |